The CrossFit Perception Gap

Bridging the Divide Between Reality and Illusion
Written by Marcus Smith
Andy McTaggart
Andy McTaggart
May 21, 2025
-
5
Mainline Class
Specialty Class
Endurance
Ladies Run Club
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
Mainline Class
Specialty Class
Endurance
Ladies Run Club
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
Mainline Class
Specialty Class
Endurance
Ladies Run Club
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
Mainline Class
Specialty Class
Endurance
Ladies Run Club
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
No items found.
The CrossFit Perception Gap

The CrossFit Perception Gap: Bridging the Divide Between Reality and Illusion

Having just completed the 2025 CrossFit Open, now is the perfect time to reflect on those intense weeks—what went well, what could be improved, and how both my clients and I experienced the journey. The Open always delivers a rollercoaster of emotions, making it vital to keep performance in perspective. At its core, CrossFit is about personal growth. It’s you versus you.

CrossFit in Dubai thrives on intensity, competition, and the constant push to surpass limits. Yet within this high-energy environment, a perception gap often forms—sometimes without us even realising. This gap reflects the difference between our current performance and the unrealistic expectations we place upon ourselves, fuelled by daily training comparisons and carefully curated social media content.

This perception gap is not exclusive to CrossFit; it echoes through our careers, relationships, and personal milestones. We often assess ourselves against external metrics and overlook our own progress. In the gym, it might be comparing our score to someone else’s on the leaderboard. In life, it might be striving for an ideal without acknowledging our own achievements.

Bridging this gap begins with honest self-awareness. Rather than obsessing over shortcomings, we should take stock of progress, set achievable goals, and appreciate the process. Whether in CrossFit or day-to-day life, growth stems from consistent effort and a clear understanding of where we’ve come from.

Now that the CrossFit Open is behind us, its lessons remain. Keep pushing, keep learning, and most of all—keep your perspective aligned.

The Myth of “I Should Be Better”

Step into any CrossFit gym in Dubai or beyond, and you’ll hear it: “I should have gone heavier.” “I should have beaten that time.” “I should be doing muscle-ups by now.” The word ‘should’ is a red flag—it reveals a gap between where we are and where we think we ought to be.

This mindset isn’t limited to CrossFit, but it is magnified in an environment where workouts are scored, progress is public, and comparison is easy. Unlike in traditional gyms, CrossFit places athletes side by side, making every session a visible performance. Combine that with the leaderboard that makes performance visible, and the relentless highlight reels on social media, and the illusion of inadequacy grows.

This same internal dialogue appears in everyday life. “I should have a better job.” “I should own a house.” “I should be further along.” Just as in CrossFit, these expectations are often rooted in comparisons that ignore the individuality of our circumstances.

The Reality Check

There’s nothing wrong with ambition. In fact, striving for better is what drives CrossFit and self-development. The problem arises when expectations outpace reality and cause frustration or burnout. Often, this happens when we compare our journey to someone else’s.

Reality in CrossFit is measurable. It’s your current lifting capacity, endurance, and technical skills—developed through consistency, coaching, and time. It’s not what you wish you could lift; it’s what you’ve earned through effort. Yes, visualisation plays a role, but it must be grounded in your actual capabilities.

The illusion is what we absorb from others’ curated success. We see best performances, not the grind behind them. We forget that top CrossFit athletes have spent years mastering the basics and training with discipline. The same principle applies to careers and personal goals: most achievements are built on long periods of quiet, consistent effort.

And here’s the reality check—without putting in the work, high-level outcomes won’t materialise. Whether you want to lift heavier, run faster, or finally get those double-unders, you need to train accordingly. In both CrossFit and life, success is earned through repeated action, not wishful thinking.

How Do We Close the Gap?

1. Track progress — Reflect on where you began, not just on where others are. Strength, endurance, and technical skill in CrossFit develop incrementally, not overnight. The same applies to mental growth—celebrating small wins creates long-term momentum.

2. Use others as inspiration, not benchmarks — That elite CrossFitter in your box or the influencer on your feed? The influencer hitting PBs daily and making life seem easy? Great for motivation, but their path isn’t yours. Everyone’s journey in CrossFit is different—respect your own pace.

3. Listen to your body and drop the ego — Training near your threshold is useful. Pushing beyond it at the expense of safety, form, or recovery is counterproductive. Injury and burnout don’t build long-term success.

4. Understand social media’s lens — A snapshot, not reality. That epic CrossFit PR post? It likely followed weeks of missed reps and rough sessions. People rarely share the full story, and that’s important to remember.

5. Stay present in your training and your life — Celebrate today's effort. Focus on being fully present during your WOD. Progress in CrossFit, like in life, comes through consistent repetition and patience. It’s never truly ‘overnight’.

I’ve felt the perception gap myself—especially early on in my CrossFit journey. Even now, it creeps in sometimes. But I’ve learnt to pause and remember why I started. For me, CrossFit is about becoming better—physically, mentally, emotionally. Still, it’s easy to lose perspective in a comparison-driven world.

The perception gap is real. But it's manageable. Belief and ambition matter—but without effort, they mean nothing. Whether you're training at your local CrossFit box or striving for growth in life, own where you are, do the work, and results will come.

Fun  - HONESTY - Simplicity - Smash Life - Mental Toughness - Hard Work